11 April 2020

Brahms 3 Kindler & Beecham (reupload)




Reuploded on request.


FLAC (separated track) & info included



Here a very interesting couple of rare Brahms 3.

Now almost forgotten, The (Dutch-born) American cellist and conductor Hans Kindler (1892-1949) was the principal cellist in Stokowski’s Philadelphia Orchestra; he gave recitals with Rachmaninov and Ravel, concerts with Monteux and Furtwängler: later, became a conductor.
In 1931 he had formed the National Symphony Orchestra in Washington and in 1940 they began to record. The major fruits were the third symphonies of Brahms and Tchaikovsky; but they recorded also shorter works and lighter repertoire.

Then, you can listen for the only surviving Brahms Third conducted by Beecham (just 2 weeks after Toscanini's death): he was a "champion" of the Second, but he conducted only a few times 1 and 3, and never the Fourth!

Both versions are vivid and energetic (listen to Sir Thomas shoutings!):
fast tempos and very flexible, unpredictable phrasing.

I don't know if these versions are on CD.
The first is from a 78rpm set; the other from a radio broadcast.
Two "outsiders", ok, in a very big discography;
but I suggest you to try :-)








4 comments:

Guido said...

https://drive.google.com/open?id=1XcLJgL4BkKa16JTsNFFipc1UFKZAUm2y

centuri said...

Thanks so much for these rarities and allow the comparison on Brahms 3.
Beecham is so unconventional and dramatic in this work .

and HAPPY EASTER dear Guido !!
Jean

Guido said...

Thanks!!

Anonymous said...

I owned the actual RCA Victor original 78 rpm set of the Kindler but the open reel dub I made went into landfill about 25 years ago. I must say that the fidelity was, for the period, rather weak and wan compared to other Victors of the time from the Saint Louis Sym, the '41 Toscanini Brahms 1, and so forth. The transfer on your upload sounds *quite* similar to what I can personally recall, directly from my own 78s. Some years back on the net, I found a transfer allegedly from some sort of foreign (non-US) RCA LP that must have come out in the late sixties or seventies; it was MUCH much duller and even more lifeless, so it was a pleasure to replace it with YOUR upload.
I have heard the allegedly best archive tapes of the Beecham broadcast & they are no less overloaded than your source, so unfortunately the (amateur offair?) recodist messed up the levels badly. Again, yours is not a problem if one knows that is THE BEST to be obtained...so far (unless a good one is secreted away somewhere and even the gonzo collectors of the NY/NJ area haven't nabbed it.)